Back from Washington
I'm back from Washington, but the return trip came at considerable expense to my sanity.
My flight was supposed to leave from Dulles's terminal G, at which one arrives by taking a crappy little bus, at 5:25. I waited for the bus... and waited and waited. And, finally, the bus came, and I sat in it... and sat and sat. And, finally, the bus left the main terminal, and it drove to terminal G... and drove and drove.
Because waiting for the bus, waiting on the non-moving bus, and riding on the bus took so much time, I was a little worried about making my flight when we eventually arrived at the terminal. So, I ran from the bus to the gate and arrived at the gate around 5:17, a full eight minutes before the flight's scheduled departure.
The gate attendant was finishing yelling at someone over her walkie-talkie, so I let her do that, and then I told her I wanted to board the Pittsburgh flight. She said, "it's gone." I said, "what?" She said, "the plane left." I looked up at the board behind her, where the plane was clearly said to depart at 5:25, and I said, "that says 5:25." She said, "boarding closes ten minutes before departure." I said, "what?!" She said, "you'll have to go talk with customer service," and she motioned me to a conveniently located customer service desk, not more than 40 feet away, with a conveniently lengthy line extending from it.
I sort of stomped over to the end of the line and called Katy, who was planning to pick me up in Pittsburgh, to tell her I had just missed a flight because I was eight minutes early for it. After I spoke with her, the guy in front of me in line asked me if I'd just missed the Pittsburgh flight. I said yes, we chatted for a few minutes about how Dulles sucks peoples' souls (in a bad way), etc., and then we stood like good Englishmen. Except I guess neither of us are really good Englishmen, but wow, Englishmen really know how to queue. Anyway...
I got to the customer service desk shortly after the other guy did, and we were both nearly simultaneously finding out that the only other flight to Pittsburgh last night was already full and that we could either be put on standby for that flight or move our flights to the following morning (but not both!). At which point, I asked the customer service idiot, "how long does it take to drive to Pittsburgh?" The guy standing next to me said, "about four hours." Thus began the long trip home.
We had a happy meeting there at the customer service desk and were excited about the prospect of sharing the cost of a rental car and driving away from that airport as quickly as possible. Standby tickets in hand in case something went awry with the car rental, Kurt and I stomped off to stand in line for the bus back to the main terminal.
The plans were in place by the time we got to the main terminal (yet another long bus ride), and there, we searched for somewhere to access rental car companies. There was a line of phones, each connected to a rental car company, near the end of the baggage claim area. Kurt started on one end, and I started on the other.
"Hello?" "I'm interested in renting a car at Washington Dulles and driving it to Pittsburgh tonight. Can you tell me how much that's going to cost in your cheapest car?" "I have a line of 25 people standing on front of me and..." "Just tell me how much it's going to cost." "We don't do one-way rentals." Click.
And so it went.
Of the many car rental companies at Dulles, only Avis and Hertz would rent cars for one-way drives. Hertz said $87, and I believe Avis said $94 (Kurt found Avis.). Off we went to stand in the cold and wait for a Hertz bus.
We were the first people off the Hertz bus, so we had our pick of rental agents oozing faux-innocence when we walked into the office. A guy helped us rent a Corolla for $140 or so (nope, not $87 -- but we could have rented one of those new Mustangs for $180, don't ya know), and soon, we were leaving the airport, maps in hand and caution to the wind.
The four-hour drive was reduced to just over three hours, even with a stop at Boston Market somewhere in Maryland, by pushing 80 m.p.h. the entire way. Hell, it's a rental, and it only snowed for most of the drive.
We drove from Dulles International Airport to Pittsburgh International Airport (I don't think driving is how people normally do that.), replenished the half a tank of gas we used, and returned the car, no more than four hours after renting it.
Kurt had parked in extended parking, so we had to take a bus to get out there from the terminal, and on the way to the bus, we passed the baggage claim where the flight on which we were standby passengers had landed only half an hour or so prior. We were amused.
Having scraped the ice and snow off his car, we [put gas in it at the same place and] drove to Shadyside, where Kurt also happens to live.
So, that was last night. Now, I want to get United to answer these questions for me and, after providing me with satisfactory responses, reimburse me for all my costs last night:
- Planes do not really leave ten minutes before their departure times. Why did your gate agent lie to me?
- You knew I was in the airport with a boarding pass. Why did you not wait for me?
- Did you leave me behind because you had already filled my seat as a result of overbooking the flight?
- Why would any airline ever instate a policy of closing boarding ten minutes before departure? And, when did you start doing this?
- Does it bother you, given the current climate of airline bankruptcy and low-fare cost cutting, that I'm never going to fly United again and that I'm going to strongly encourage everyone I know to do the same?
As it turns out, Kurt's a really cool guy doing a post-doc at Pitt, and if I ever have free time in Pittsburgh again, we'll probably do drinks or coffee or dinner or something. And, as it turns out, we may have met each other anyway, because our seats for the flight were 4C and 4D.
United Airlines, I hate you, and you'll be hearing from me soon.
Comments
I believe that is the reason that I fly only on American Airlines. I hate all others.
That is really strange that you and Kurt would have been sitting next to each other. Isn't it weird how things happen?
Posted by: hmh | December 5, 2005 04:26 PM
I read your United story, and I agree that you received bad customer service. However, I believe that United did the right thing by all of the other clients that did manage to make it to the gate before the cut-off time. Of course, I don't work for United Airlines, but I would like to take a guess at the answers that you will probably receive to your questions. This is what I think the airline will say: (Disclosure: None of the following is meant to be taken personally.)
Colin: Planes do not really leave ten minutes before their departure time. Why did your gate agent lie to me?
If you made it to the gate 7 minutes prior to departure, then you did make it after the boarding cut-off time. Of course, at that very moment, the plane was still at the gate, but for all practical purposes, the plane may as well have left, because you're not getting on the plane anyway. So when the gate agent said, "The plane left," it may not be technically true, but it's true as far as you're concerned.
Colin: You knew I was in the airport with a boarding pass. Why did you not wait for me?
We did know that you were in the boarding area. Why did we not wait for you? How long are we supposed to wait? The published departure time is the time that the plane pushes back from the gate. Before pushback though, the flight crew has to prepare the plane for departure, which can take up to five minutes. How many minutes before departure should we continue to allow people to board? Using your logic, we may as well allow people to board 23 seconds before the departure time. This is simply not practical. We at the airline believe that a cut-off time 10 minutes before departure is ample time for people to arrive at the gate. Of course, as in your situation, not everyone will be able to make it to the gate in time, but we have to balance the individual client's needs against the needs of those people who did manage to get to the gate on time.
Colin: Did you leave me behind because you had already filled my seat as a result of overbooking the flight?
No, we left you behind because you did not fulfill the terms and conditions of the "contract" that was made at the time that you purchased your airline ticket. When you purchased your ticket, you were clearly told to arrive no later than ten minutes prior to departure. We understand that you had trouble getting to the gate as a result of things that were out of your control, but are we to be held responsible for this, as those things are out of our control as well? I think you would agree that it is no one's fault that you arrived late to the gate, it's just something that unfortunately happened. Now, 160 other people did manage to fulfill the terms of their contract. From a business perspective, we should not fail on our part of our contract to them as a result of your failure to fulfill your contract with us.
Colin: Why would any airline ever instate a policy of closing boarding ten minutes prior to departure? And when did you start doing that?
We close the boarding process ten minutes prior to departure so that we can secure the plane and prepare for pushback. We know that you are not aware of all of the procedures involved in this, but needless to say, it is an extensive process. We started doing this several decades ago. With recent new legislation in place, airlines are held to an even higher scrutiny when it comes to securing aircraft. Allowing people to board the plane even up to five minutes before departure would severely hamper our ability to comply with federal regulations.
Colin: Does it bother you that I will never fly United again and I will encourage all my friends not to fly United as well?
Of course it bothers us. We would certainly like your business, but their are rules to airline travel. And it is very difficult to accomodate every customer who breaks the rules and wants us to act like they didn't break the rules. Again, we try to do what's best by every customer, but not when such action adversely effects hundreds of other customers. We know you will fly other airlines in the future, but, if you break the rules again, you will probably have an ever-growing list of "never fly again" airlines.
Posted by: arc | December 5, 2005 08:31 PM
Well I guess you are going to drive across every state at some point this year. And AirTrans does the same thing. They close doors 10 min before departure time and leave the desk empty for the 5 min before that. So if you are 15 min early for a flight, as I had been in Atlanta due to stupid people in security lines, you will not be allowed on the plane.
Posted by: dla | December 6, 2005 01:20 PM